HARRISBURG — Ahead of the 2016 presidential election, Dwayne Heisler knocked on thousands of doors to talk to voters and he was amazed at how many Democrats in Central Pennsylvania told him they were going to vote for Donald Trump.
Heisler, chairman of the progressive caucus for the state Democratic Party, said he tried to warn other Democratic leaders about the level of enthusiasm for Trump.
“All I heard was: Republicans are smarter than that,” and won’t support Trump, Heisler said.
But buoyed by support from blue-collar Democrats, Trump ended up flipping counties that have historically voted for Democrats, and ran up dominating numbers in rural parts of the state that traditionally vote for Republicans, said Kevan Yenerall, a political science professor at Clarion University of Pennsylvania.
Supporters like Carol Lynne Ryan of Lawrence County are confident that Trump will prevail in Pennsylvania again.
“I think he’s in better shape than he was in 2016 at this time,” Ryan said. “I think there’s a silent majority of Americans who support the president.”
Ryan said that Trump still appeals to voters who think the president is supporting the nation’s military and “putting America first.”
2012 to 2016
It's not difficult to pinpoint how Trump won Pennsylvania in 2016.
President Barack Obama won Erie County by 19,000 votes in 2012; Trump got 2,000 more votes than Hillary Clinton there four years later.
Obama won Northampton County by 6,000 votes in 2012; Trump won the county by almost 5,500 votes.
And in the biggest swing, Obama won Luzerne County by 6,000 votes in 2012; Trump won that county by 26,000 votes.
In an election where Trump won the state by just over 44,000 votes, the swing in those three counties made the difference, he said.
On top of that, while Clinton won in Philadelphia handily, she got almost 5,000 fewer votes than Obama did in 2016 and Trump got 12,000 more Republican votes than Republican Mitt Romney did in 2012 in Philadelphia.
'Trickier' this time
Marc Scaringi of Cumberland County said he became a Trump supporter in 2015 because he thought the then-candidate was hitting the right notes on trade, foreign policy and immigration.
“He captured so much of the conservative base that has been ignored by the Republican Party establishment,” Scaringi said.
But with the state and nation grappling with the impact of a pandemic and no way of knowing how bad the coronavirus outbreak will be in the fall when voters head to the polls, it’s difficult to be certain about Trump’s prospects for winning again, Scaringi said.
“This time it’s trickier,” he said.
Scaringi said that he thinks Trump has identified messages that will appeal his supporters in pushing back against moves to remove historic monuments.
“He’s hitting his stride with his full-throated defense of traditional American culture and defending monuments from vandalizing and removal,” Scaringi said.
Whether those appeals will be enough certainly isn’t clear, according to national polls.
Sabato’s Crystal Ball, produced by the University of Virginia’s Center for Politics last week moved Pennsylvania from a “toss-up” to “Leans Biden.” The Center also shifted Florida from “Leans Trump” to a “toss-up.”
Any conclusions about the state of the race in July “need to be taken with a grain of salt,” Yenerall said, noting that at this time, polls had Clinton leading, as well.
Most pundits under-appreciated the level of support that Trump was generating in 2016, he said.
One key difference in 2020 will likely be that Democrat voters may be more energized to seek to unseat Trump than they were when voting in 2016, Yenerall said.
“It’s hard to imagine that Democrats will be complacent in 2020,” he said.
Heisler said that because the 2016 election was so close in Pennsylvania, it’s hard to pick the exact tipping point that gave Trump the victory.
He remembers thinking that Clinton had committed a serious blunder in March 2016 when she said at a town hall that her energy policy would “put a lot of coal miners and coal companies out of business.”
Heisler said that he also thought that media reporting focusing on Clinton’s health was damaging.
Randy Shannon of Beaver County said that for Democrats, the election is going to be more about Trump than Biden.
“Biden doesn’t matter. Trump is what matters. Getting him out is paramount,” Shannon said.
While Biden may not be an exciting candidate, Democrats recognize that with him in office, they will be able to focus on issues important to them, including expanding access to government-provided health care coverage, he said.
John Finnerty reports from the Harrisburg Bureau for The Meadville Tribune and other Pennsylvania newspapers owned by CNHI. Email him at firstname.lastname@example.org and follow him on Twitter @cnhipa.