Meadville Tribune

State News

July 5, 2013

Bill would shield docs 'sorry' for treatment mishaps

HARRISBURG — In 2004, Danielle Bellerose gave birth prematurely to twin girls at a hospital in Massachusetts. Eight days later, one of the babies died.

Bellerose tried to question hospital staff about why the complications that killed her daughter were not recognized more quickly. But no one at the hospital would share any information with her. Eventually, Bellerose filed a malpractice lawsuit, and seven years after her daughter’s death, she was awarded $11 million.

It is the kind of case that gives doctors and hospital administrators nightmares. The Bellerose lawsuit also demonstrates how poor communication between hospital staff and families of patients can drive people to file malpractice lawsuits, said Dan Davis, director of bioethics for Geisinger Health System, based in Danville. And it’s the exact kind of case that lawmakers hope to avert by new legislation intended to shield doctors who apologize after something goes wrong with a patient’s medical treatment. The push for the legislation has been led by Republican Sens. Pat Vance of Dauphin County and Gene Yaw of Lycoming County.

Specifically, the bill makes any benevolent gesture made prior to the commencement of a medical liability action by a health care provider, assisted living residence or personal care home inadmissible as evidence of liability or an admission against interest.

Vance’s bill passed the Senate and now goes to the House of Representatives.

Thirty-six states, the District of Columbia and Guam have provisions allowing medical professionals to make apologies or sympathetic gestures.

The bill was backed by dozens of business and medical advocacy groups. Proponents say that doctors frightened of the specter of malpractice lawsuits may not speak openly with patients and their loved ones. But the failure to communicate often fuels the feeling that the hospital or doctor erred and doesn’t care about the human costs.

Vance said that studies have shown that a large percentage of patients and families may not have filed medical malpractice suits if given an explanation and an apology regarding the event.

“I think this piece of legislation is a great compromise,” Yaw said. “It allows doctors to make expressions of sympathy without fear that those expressions will be used as a weapon against them, yet the legislation still preserves the rights of individuals to pursue claims for substandard health care.”

The trend toward protecting medical apologies probably began almost 15 years ago when a landmark study determined there are an estimated 98,000 medical errors in U.S. hospitals each year, Davis said.

Based on that finding, health systems began to explore what they could do to improve their operations to limit medical mistakes.

Legislation protecting doctors who acknowledge to loved ones that something went wrong is a natural byproduct, Davis said.

“I understand this as another chapter in the evolution of physician attitudes toward truth-telling,” he said.

Many hospitals have adopted policies spelling out exactly how patients or their loved ones ought to be told when something goes wrong, Davis said.

“If the aim is to be benevolent, honesty is the far better means to that end than deception,” Davis said. “(At Geisinger), we have an explicit policy that you should disclose, within 24 hours, a medical error that poses an actual or possibility of harm.”

An apology is supposed to be part of that disclosure process.

Finnerty reports from Harrisburg for Community Newspaper Holdings Inc.’s Pennsylvania newspapers, including The Meadville Tribune. Follow him on Twitter @cnhipa.

Text Only
State News
  • Well inspectors trying to keep up during boom time

    The state’s 83 well inspectors face a daunting enough challenge keeping tabs on 120,000 active oil and gas wells that have been drilled over the last century.

    July 27, 2014

  • PennDOT seeking outside help to make bridge repairs

    State officials are poised to sign a massive deal that will enlist outside help to rebuild and maintain up to 600 bridges, marking the Corbett administration’s latest foray into privatizing key government functions.

    July 24, 2014

  • Gov. Corbett pressures lawmakers in pension fight

    Gov. Tom Corbett is ratcheting up pressure on the Legislature to reform the state’s pension system by focusing on how often school districts use tax increases to offset costs.

    July 22, 2014

  • Experts: Expanding coverage fuels doc shortage

    Pennsylvania’s health care system absorbed more than 300,000 new patients who signed up for insurance through Obamacare’s exchanges. But experts worry the system can’t handle another wave of patients, twice as large, should the state expand Medicaid under the Affordable Care Act.

    July 13, 2014

  • Jerry Sandusky’s son tells story to Oprah Winfrey

    Jerry Sandusky’s adult son is speaking out about what he says was sexual abuse by his father.

    July 8, 2014

  • Environmentalists criticize drilling-for-dollars plan in state forests and parks

    Pennsylvania’s just finished budget calls for raising almost $100 million by expanding leases for gas development in state forests — even though leases the state has already issued are far from tapped out.

    July 3, 2014

  • Pennsylvania House approves Republicans' $29.1B budget

    The Legislature voted late Monday to put a looming, $1.5 billion shortfall in its rearview mirror, with a deal to pass a $29.1 billion budget that increases state spending by 1.8 percent but doesn’t hike taxes.

    June 30, 2014

  • Food safety delivery concerns rise with fuel prices

    A few weeks ago state agriculture inspectors forced a trucker to toss 2,000 pounds of food in the garbage after finding the cargo had not been kept at safe temperatures.

    June 15, 2014

  • Tow truckers hope to put brakes on dispatch system

    Some tow truck operators are boycotting a computerized dispatch system put in place by state police, complaining that it’s confusing and leads to longer response times than when troopers and dispatchers manage a call.

    June 1, 2014

  • 'Economics' of state gubernatorial campaigns

    Gov. Tom Corbett’s re-election campaign hailed April’s jobs numbers. Pennsylvania’s unemployment dipped to 5.7 percent — its lowest since 2008 and well below the national average of 6.3 percent.
    “The people of Pennsylvania elected me to Harrisburg on my promise of less taxes and more jobs, and we continue to see that promise ringing tr

    May 25, 2014

Business Marquee
AP Video
Traditional African Dishes Teach Healthy Eating The Carbon Trap: US Exports Global Warming 13 Struck by Lightning on Calif. Beach Baseball Hall of Famers Inducted Israel, Hamas Trade Fire Despite Truce in Gaza Italy's Nibali Set to Win First Tour De France Raw: Shipwrecked Concordia Completes Last Voyage Raw: Sea Turtle Hatchlings Emerge From Nest Raw: Massive Dust Storm Covers Phoenix 12-hour Cease-fire in Gaza Fighting Begins Raw: Bolivian Dancers Attempt to Break Record Raw: Israel, Palestine Supporters Rally in US Raw: Air Algerie Flight 5017 Wreckage Virginia Governor Tours Tornado Aftermath Judge Faces Heat Over Offer to Help Migrant Kids Kangaroo Goes Missing in Oklahoma More M17 Bodies Return, Sanctions on Russia Grow Raw: Deadly Tornado Hits Virginia Campground Ohio State Marching Band Chief Fired After Probe Raw: Big Rig Stuck in Illinois Swamp
Hyperlocal Search
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide