Meadville Tribune

Opinion

July 17, 2013

Citizens have to accept privacy limits to enjoy freedom

Edward Snowden released classified U.S. government information about the National Intelligence Surveillance Program for protecting the American population from terrorist attacks. Some liberal groups call him a hero for protecting the privacy of citizens. Politicians, both liberal and conservative, accuse him of treason for endangering the whole American population.

Was the National Security Agency’s surveillance system an essential system for protection of innocent life or was it an unnecessary violation of the privacy of many? Let’s try to put these questions in an historical and philosophical perspective.

Every respected philosophy has a theory of human existence and a built-in ethics or theory of right and wrong. Classical western philosophies linked both theories with an understanding of nature as a divine creation. Created nature explained the sanctity of human life and served as a guide for distinguishing right from wrong acts.

Modern philosophies, of the 18th and 19th century Enlightenment period, shift thinking away from a background theory of creation. Nature in modern era thinking is the reality accessed by scientific methodology and expressed in scientific laws. Measurable regularities of the physical world become the modern meaning of nature. Theology is dropped in favor of physical sciences: explanations based only on material reality and efficient causes.

The term Natural Law traditionally referred to moral principles rooted in divine creation, which govern human behavior. Now, Natural Law refers to predictable properties of things. Nature moved from being a divine creation and a norm for human behavior to being a reality able to be measured and predicted by the use of scientific methodologies.

Even in modern times, however, for some thinkers Natural Law retained a moral sense. It referred to the self evident moral rules and principles of moral behavior. Principles of Natural Law became Natural Rights, i.e. moral directives that were unarguable; that were valid independent of religion or theology. This was an Enlightenment or modern meaning of Natural Law. It was a minimalistic theory of nature and law.

Some Enlightenment period thinkers, however, retained a more traditional theological perspective. We see this expressed in The American Declaration of Independence. The opening paragraph spoke of “Laws of Nature and of Nature’s God.” The next paragraph declared that “these truths are self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.”

The natural rights of life, liberty and happiness today are all threatened by terrorists. The U.S. government’s different responses to these threats are reflections of government’s primary obligations. To threaten the human life of citizens is the greatest threat to the most basic right of all citizens.

In modern Enlightenment thinking, however, besides the government’s obligation to protect the right to life, there is also the obligation to protect liberty and the freedom of citizens. Human beings in more modern thinking are defined essentially by an ability to choose. Free choice or autonomy became the defining human characteristic that had to be protected by government.

Now, a government obligation to protect human life is joined with a government obligation to protect individual freedom. Privacy enters the scene and becomes important because it is a condition for the exercise of individual freedom and not being treated as an object.

Instead of dividing the U.S. population into opposing camps over Snowden’s destruction of a surveillance system used by National Security Agency, the issue needs to be seen in a more historical and philosophical perspective. On one side are those focused on every citizen’s right to life and the government’s obligation to protect that right. On the other side are those offended by a government surveillance system because it is seen as a violation of privacy.

Seen in historical perspective, there is reason for compromise between the opposing camps. The most reasonable response is not to defame those holding a different opinion but rather to look for compromise and reconciliation based on the American Declaration of Independence and broadly recognized rights to both life and liberty.

The American population today has to be protected against terrorism. The first obligation of government is protection of innocent life. If this can be done without intrusion into privacy or any limitation of individual freedom, this would be ideal. In the real world today, however, citizens who value life and want human life to be protected have to be willing to accept some limits on their privacy and their individual freedom.

Snowden claims that his individual liberty and the freedom of all others trumps the value of human life and government obligation to protect the right to life of citizens. He even claims that his preferred right to privacy and freedom extends to terrorists and therefore protects their opportunity to do terrible evil to innocent others. Digital sophistication does not guarantee even the most basic moral development.

Drane, Ph.D., is the Russell Roth Professor of Bioethics at Edinboro University of Pennsylvania.

1
Text Only
Opinion
  • It’s hard to believe park will turn things around until secrecy ends

    Even if a deal is struck to save Conneaut Lake Park from a pending sale to pay off back taxes, it appears unlikely that the park will succeed unless its new managers pledge themselves to transparency and public accountability.

    April 22, 2014 1 Story

  • Public pensions for private lobbyists under fire

    Employees of the Pennsylvania School Board Association don’t work for any of the state’s 500 local school districts — not directly, anyway. They lobby lawmakers on behalf of those districts for things like funding.

    April 20, 2014

  • Many veterans suffer PTSD, which needs to be dealt with

    Initially, I intended this article to be about PTSD “Post Traumatic Stress Disorder.” I wanted to write about the myths and misconceptions that those four words may hold. But as the days went by, the story just wouldn’t come together for me. Everything I typed seemed to miss something. There was no feeling.

    April 17, 2014

  • Journalists in combat zones ‘write with light’ while risking their lives

    I first heard the news on National Public Radio on my car radio. On April 4, the day before elections in Afghanistan, an Afghan military officer walked up to a car in a convoy and opened fire. Anja Niedringhaus, a staff photographer for The Associated Press, died instantly.

    April 16, 2014

  • There’s no war on men and boys — it’s quite the opposite

    Two weeks ago, Paul Dici submitted an column titled “It’s time to fight against the war on men and boys” (March 28). Mr. Dici would have us believe that men and boys are being “wussified” by a progressive agenda that may jeopardize our national security. Also, he makes the point that men and boys are not given the same advantages (programs) as women and girls.

    April 14, 2014

  • McCord outsourcing ‘scandal’ reminds me of Y2K fears

    With only seven weeks to go until the May primary election, the campaigns are expected to get a lot hotter and more negative.

    April 13, 2014

  • Can we trust luck when it comes to the nuclear industry?

    Let’s review the history to better understand a major concern of today.

    April 11, 2014

  • Aging — is it a disease to be cured?

    If you are already old, get ready for what comes next. If you are not old yet but on the way, it is not too early to start thinking about aging and dying, because both are part of being human.

    April 10, 2014

  • Local high school students help keep future of journalism bright

    Significant technological and economic changes have caused some to question the future of journalism, both as a viable business enterprise and as a potential career. But if the proceedings of the eighth annual Northwest Pennsylvania High School Journalism Day are any indication, journalism is alive and well, especially in Crawford County.

    April 10, 2014

  • Reps want to hang ‘English only’ sign at the Capitol

    Pennsylvania, it turns out, is one of 19 states that have failed to address the menace that is non-English. Or maybe it’s un-English? Or dis-English? There must be a word for it.

    April 8, 2014

Business Marquee
AP Video
SKorea Ferry Toll Hits 156, Search Gets Tougher Video Shows Possible Syrian Gas Attack Cubs Superfans Celebrate Wrigley's 100th Raw: Cattle Truck Overturns in Texas Admirers Flock to Dole During Kansas Homecoming Raw: Erupting Volcanoes in Guatemala and Peru Alibaba IPO Could Be Largest Ever for Tech Firm FBI Joining Probe of Suburban NY 'Swatting' Call U.S. Paratroopers in Poland, Amid Ukraine Crisis US Reviews Clemency for Certain Inmates Raw: Violence Erupts in Rio Near Olympic Venue Raw: Deadly Bombing in Egypt Raw: What's Inside a Commercial Jet Wheel Well Raw: Obama Arrives in Japan for State Visit Raw: Anti-Obama Activists Fight Manila Police Motels Near Disney Fighting Homeless Problem Michigan Man Sees Thanks to 'bionic Eye' S.C. Man Apologizes for Naked Walk in Wal-Mart Chief Mate: Crew Told to Escape After Passengers
Hyperlocal Search
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
Stocks