Meadville Tribune


January 24, 2014

While same-sex case looms, late-night comics give verdict

This week, our governor made an unintended appearance on “The Daily Show” with Jon Stewart, as the punchline of gag about a “Homophobic Olympics.”

Stewart’s “correspondent” Aasif Mandvi offered up the bizarre case of a Utah man who went on a hunger strike to protest gay marriage in that state. Stewart pooh-poohed the incident as “run-of-the-mill ignorance.”

It would take “a Lake Placid hockey miracle” to go up against the likes of Russian President Vladimir Putin in a competition of the most stark examples of homophobia, Stewart opined.

So where did “The Daily Show” turn for an American case of intolerance to compete against the likes of Nigeria, Uganda and Russia? It was Gov. Tom Corbett’s bungled attempt, in a television interview, to justify a ban on same-sex marriage by comparing it to incest between siblings.

The segment ends with Mandvi screaming, “Do you believe in ignorance?” and chants of “USA, USA!”

Pennsylvania’s status as a lightning rod of controversy stems from its position as the only mid-Atlantic state to bar same-sex marriage — a distinction that will soon be examined in court.

Advocates for gay marriage have expressed cautious optimism that 2014 could be the year that Pennsylvania’s ban is overturned. A federal judge has scheduled a summer trial for a challenge by the ACLU.

The law is being defended by the governor’s Office of General Counsel, with the help of outside legal experts. The general counsel was compelled to take over the case after Democratic Attorney General Kathleen Kane punted.

“I cannot ethically defend the constitutionality of Pennsylvania’s version of DOMA where I believe it to be wholly unconstitutional,” Kane said, referring to the federal Defense of Marriage Act.

Her decision outraged conservative lawmakers and prompted firebrand House state government committee chairman Rep. Daryl Metcalfe to author a resolution calling for Kane’s impeachment.

“Attorney General Kane has created a constitutional crisis by refusing to perform her assigned role and usurping the role of the courts,” Metcalfe argued in a memo to other lawmakers. “It is our duty to stop her from engaging in further misbehavior in office.”

Just five of the 203 representatives in the House signed on as co-sponsors of Metcalfe’s resolution.

An analysis of the issue by the Columbia Law Review noted that the right of an attorney general or chief executive to refuse to defend a law they deem unconstitutional has been argued since the earliest days of the nation.

Thomas Jefferson, upon taking office, resolved that the Sedition Act passed during the Adams administration was unconstitutional. Though a number of judicial reviews had determined that the Sedition Act was legal, Jefferson announced that because he believed it to be unconstitutional, he was going to ignore it.

Such executive decisions have arisen repeatedly over the last two centuries, with standards shifting a little here or there. In federal law, the bottom line has always been that presidents and attorneys general may refuse to defend laws they think are unconstitutional. Attorney General Eric Holder, for one, refused to defend the federal Defense of Marriage Act.

Kane was not the first attorney general to decline to defend a state law banning same-sex marriage, noted Leslie Cooper, a senior attorney in the ACLU’s New York office. In California, Gov. Jerry Brown, as attorney general, made an identical decision following that state’s Prop 8 ballot initiative, she said.

This week in Virginia, Attorney General Mark Herring announced that his office is supporting efforts to get that state’s same-sex marriage ban ruled unconstitutional.

A spokesman for Kane said she reached the same conclusion independently.

“There was no consultation in either direction,” spokesman Joe Peters said in a Thursday email. “This was Attorney General Kane’s decision based on the law, her oath of office to defend the Constitutions of Pennsylvania and the U.S., and ethical obligations as a lawyer to ensure constitutionally guaranteed equality for all.”

Corbett does not stand alone in his determination to defend the state’s law, of course. Republican attorneys general in Ohio and Utah are leading efforts to appeal federal court rulings in same-sex marriage cases.

As the court of late-night comedy issues its verdict on same-sex marriage, we seem to be racing toward a conclusion in the real courts, as well.

John Finnerty reports from the CNHI Harrisburg Bureau for The Meadville Tribune and other Pennsylvania newspapers owned by Community Newspaper Holdings Inc. Email him at and follow him on Twitter @cnhipa.

Text Only
  • It’s hard to believe park will turn things around until secrecy ends

    Even if a deal is struck to save Conneaut Lake Park from a pending sale to pay off back taxes, it appears unlikely that the park will succeed unless its new managers pledge themselves to transparency and public accountability.

    April 22, 2014 1 Story

  • Public pensions for private lobbyists under fire

    Employees of the Pennsylvania School Board Association don’t work for any of the state’s 500 local school districts — not directly, anyway. They lobby lawmakers on behalf of those districts for things like funding.

    April 20, 2014

  • Many veterans suffer PTSD, which needs to be dealt with

    Initially, I intended this article to be about PTSD “Post Traumatic Stress Disorder.” I wanted to write about the myths and misconceptions that those four words may hold. But as the days went by, the story just wouldn’t come together for me. Everything I typed seemed to miss something. There was no feeling.

    April 17, 2014

  • Journalists in combat zones ‘write with light’ while risking their lives

    I first heard the news on National Public Radio on my car radio. On April 4, the day before elections in Afghanistan, an Afghan military officer walked up to a car in a convoy and opened fire. Anja Niedringhaus, a staff photographer for The Associated Press, died instantly.

    April 16, 2014

  • There’s no war on men and boys — it’s quite the opposite

    Two weeks ago, Paul Dici submitted an column titled “It’s time to fight against the war on men and boys” (March 28). Mr. Dici would have us believe that men and boys are being “wussified” by a progressive agenda that may jeopardize our national security. Also, he makes the point that men and boys are not given the same advantages (programs) as women and girls.

    April 14, 2014

  • McCord outsourcing ‘scandal’ reminds me of Y2K fears

    With only seven weeks to go until the May primary election, the campaigns are expected to get a lot hotter and more negative.

    April 13, 2014

  • Can we trust luck when it comes to the nuclear industry?

    Let’s review the history to better understand a major concern of today.

    April 11, 2014

  • Aging — is it a disease to be cured?

    If you are already old, get ready for what comes next. If you are not old yet but on the way, it is not too early to start thinking about aging and dying, because both are part of being human.

    April 10, 2014

  • Local high school students help keep future of journalism bright

    Significant technological and economic changes have caused some to question the future of journalism, both as a viable business enterprise and as a potential career. But if the proceedings of the eighth annual Northwest Pennsylvania High School Journalism Day are any indication, journalism is alive and well, especially in Crawford County.

    April 10, 2014

  • Reps want to hang ‘English only’ sign at the Capitol

    Pennsylvania, it turns out, is one of 19 states that have failed to address the menace that is non-English. Or maybe it’s un-English? Or dis-English? There must be a word for it.

    April 8, 2014