Mike Tomlin might be a perfectionist, but he’s a realist too.
The Pittsburgh Steelers coach knows penalties are going to happen. He can tolerate mistakes — to a point anyway — and makes no excuses when he sees the flag fly.
It’s just that he’d prefer not to see the yellow hankies in flight so often, which at the moment seems to be nearly all the time.
The Steelers (2-2), who have long prided themselves on their discipline, are playing like a team that doesn’t have much. Pittsburgh leads the NFL in penalties per game (9.2) and penalty yards per game (86.5) and is on pace to shatter team records in both categories.
“In some instances we have some guys working hard and not necessarily smart,” Tomlin said. “Those things usually smooth themselves out as you push through the first quarter of the season.”
Maybe, but at this point there’s nowhere to go but up heading into Thursday’s game at Tennessee (1-4). While penalties were up across the league when the replacement officials were working, they’ve come back down to earth a bit since the regular referees returned to work.
Just not in Pittsburgh.
The Steelers were flagged nine times for 106 yards in a 16-14 win over Philadelphia last week and were fortunate the repeated miscues didn’t send them to their first two-game losing streak in three years.
Personal foul penalties on safeties Ryan Clark and Ryan Mundy gave the Eagles 30 free yards on a third quarter touchdown drive that got Philadelphia back in the game and left guard Willie Colon’s holding penalty on the first play of Pittsburgh’s final possession — the fourth flag Colon drew on the day — pushed the Steelers all the way back to their 10.
Pittsburgh rallied behind quarterback Ben Roethlisberger but the Steelers are well aware they don’t have a ton of wiggle room as it is and handing out a football field’s worth of penalty yardage a game isn’t exactly good for business.
“They’re just small mental errors,” center Maurkice Pouncey said. “It’s a part of football. Sometimes it happens. That’s something that we’ve got to tighten up if we want to be the team we want to be.”
Perhaps, but the truth is the Steelers have climbed the ranks of the most penalized teams in the league under Tomlin. Pittsburgh was one of the eight fewest penalized teams in the NFL in each of Bill Cowher’s finals three years on the sideline.
Since Tomlin took over in 2007, the trend has reversed. The Steelers have been among the 10 most penalized teams three times over the last five seasons and barring a significant and immediate downturn will make it four out of six this fall.
The flags haven’t stopped Pittsburgh from being one of the league’s elite teams, but the club’s margin for error is slimmer than ever. The Steelers are 0-2 on the road this year, including a 34-31 setback in Oakland last month in which the Raiders used a handful of Pittsburgh infractions to put together a spirited fourth-quarter comeback.
The Steelers insist they’re not trying to develop a reputation, but they may have gotten one anyway. Linebacker James Harrison has enjoyed a steady stream of fines over the last three years while Mundy has already been docked $21,000 for his helmet-to-helmet hit on Oakland wide receiver Darrius Heyward-Bey that knocked Heyward-Bey out cold.
A second fine could be coming if league officials feel the 15-yard penalty Mundy received for slamming into Philadelphia’s Jeremy Maclin on Sunday wasn’t sufficient.
If Harrison can be honest, however, he doesn’t think either Mundy or Clark deserved a flag.
“Ryan (Mundy), didn’t look like it hit helmet-to-helmet, but the guy made like he was hurt and if it looks like the guy is hurt, let’s throw a flag and worry about it later,” Harrison said.
The four-time Pro Bowler and former Defensive Player of the Year added he’s not sure all teams are being treated equally, saying he frequently sees players from different teams commit similar acts. One player will get fined while the other avoids trouble altogether.
“I just think they need to display or execute the rules evenly across the board,” Harrison said.
Cornerback Ike Taylor is a little more diplomatic, saying the referees have “a tough job” and that “life ain’t fair” while nose tackle Casey Hampton says it’s nearly impossible to avoid certain collisions.
“You try to hit a guy that’s moving full speed and see if you’re not going to hit him in the head every now and then,” Hampton said. “It’s just part of this business, something you’ve got to work on. Not sure how much more you can do.”
What the Steelers know they have to do, however, is be on their best behavior. Colon, who switched from right tackle to left guard this season, admits he didn’t make it difficult on the refs against the Eagles. He allowed his four holding calls were all pretty blatant and blamed his own poor technique and overaggression for drawing the attention of the umpire.
“I’ve got to do a better job,” Colon said. “If they’re targeting me, I’ve got to give them a reason not to.”
Tomlin remains optimistic his team will fall back into the norm and while players like Colon can work on their form, Tomlin will never make his players apologize for playing hard.
“I’d rather say ‘whoa’ than ‘sic’em,”’ Tomlin said.
Mike Tomlin might be a perfectionist, but he’s a realist too.
- National Sports
One-sided ruling against Rodriguez makes statement for clean baseball
Alex Rodriguez's team of lawyers and public relations people portray him as the victim of a conspiracy. Regardless of the defense Rodriguez offers, the New York Yankees star isn't believable.
Why do pro athletes recover before you do?
It's a mystery: When we twist our ankle playing tennis, it can take weeks to heal, but when a pro athlete does it, he often misses barely a beat.
Changes to NCAA foul rules could lead to free-throw marathons
I attended a Big Ten basketball game in Bloomington, Ind., a few years ago where I was seated so close to the floor that I had to keep my feet pinned under my chair so I wouldn’t trip the referee as he raced up and down the court. The view from courtside left me with one shocking reaction: I no longer had any idea what was a foul.
Coaches grapple with line between discipline and abuse
The outrage was visceral last spring when ESPN aired the damning video showing Rutgers men's basketball coach Mike Rice shoving his players, hurling gay slurs and throwing basketballs at their heads.
Is the NCAA a sinking ship?
The daily flow of bad news chronicling the NCAA seems to fall somewhere between damaging and defeated. By comparison, the NCAA’s myriad problems make the Obama Administration’s roll out of the Affordable Care Act look smooth.
VIDEOS: Memorable MLB postseason celebrations
Some of baseball's most enduring October memories are punctuated by jubilant celebrations. Take a look back at some of the most memorable expressions of joy in Major League Baseball's postseason by players and teams after the final out.
The most insufferable fans in sports live in St. Louis
The Cardinals are a very good baseball team. Their fans have every right to be happy. You can't blame the rest of us for not sharing their joy, though.
Maybe we should rethink the post-game handshake
The Kentucky High School Athletic Association has advised educators to rethink the long-standing tradition of teams shaking hands after athletic events. Is sportsmanship dead in the Bluegrass State?
- Dangerous, deadly falls from sports stadiums A 30-year-old man fell about 65 feet to his death at an Atlanta Braves game at Turner Field Monday evening. Details on what caused the fall are unknown. There have been several other deadly or dangerous falls in sports stadiums in recent years.
NFL injury risk has Hall-of-Fame dad concerned for rookie son
Kyle Long is going into the family business. "Some people are third-generation carpenters, and that's what they do," his father says. "Well, we hit people."
- More National Sports Headlines
- One-sided ruling against Rodriguez makes statement for clean baseball